Difference between revisions of "Judging a Bot"

From RA2Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(That clean and messy thing belongs to the "building skill" category.)
Line 1: Line 1:
 
When builders judge a particular robot, they most likely use or refer to one or more of these four criteria:
 
When builders judge a particular robot, they most likely use or refer to one or more of these four criteria:
  
'''Building skill:''' How well is the bot optimized and "well-built" - basically a good choice and placement of components.
+
'''Building skill:''' How well is the bot optimized and "well-built" - a well built bot consists a good choice and placement of components (includes wheel choice, drive choice, battery power, weapon choice, etc), as well as a tight chassis. A subtype of this is "clean" or "messy". A clean bot will have minimal and strategically placed extender work, a correct weapon setup and an appropriate chassis. A messy bot will most likely have an unpractical chassis shape and a lot of weight wasted on unneccesary extender work.
  
'''Efficiency:''' How well a robot fairs in battle.
+
'''Efficiency:''' How well a robot fairs in battle, ranges from "SFTW" to "killer". It is nearly always linked to building skill. It can differ depending of the arena, as well as whether you're using Stock or DSL - while it is possible to make killers out of a lot of designs, the most efficient designs still are [[HS]] and [[Popup]]s. In DSL, you can make a killer of nearly every basic design.
  
'''Creativity/Originality:''' How uncommon or new (that is, never before seen) is the robot's design.
+
'''Creativity/Originality:''' How uncommon or new is the robot's design - ranges from "clone" to" never before seen". However, overly new designs sometimes tend to be less efficient than old and more "experienced" robot designs. There are exceptions, like when [[Popups]] and [[Jugglers]] were created for the first time.
  
'''Looks:''' Some builders pay special attention on their robot's cool looks. May be component placement, artful paintjob or both.
+
'''Looks:''' Some builders pay special attention on their robot's cool looks. May be component placement, artful paintjob or both. Note that sacrificing sheer efficiency for better looks can happen easily.
 
 
'''Clean or Messy''' The difference between a really good bot and an amazing bot is whether it is clean or messy. This is usually how sleek it is, if the extenders are miniml and well thought out, if the weapons are all facing the same way (like on a popup), and if it is too wide or too skinny.
 

Revision as of 08:53, 19 December 2009

When builders judge a particular robot, they most likely use or refer to one or more of these four criteria:

Building skill: How well is the bot optimized and "well-built" - a well built bot consists a good choice and placement of components (includes wheel choice, drive choice, battery power, weapon choice, etc), as well as a tight chassis. A subtype of this is "clean" or "messy". A clean bot will have minimal and strategically placed extender work, a correct weapon setup and an appropriate chassis. A messy bot will most likely have an unpractical chassis shape and a lot of weight wasted on unneccesary extender work.

Efficiency: How well a robot fairs in battle, ranges from "SFTW" to "killer". It is nearly always linked to building skill. It can differ depending of the arena, as well as whether you're using Stock or DSL - while it is possible to make killers out of a lot of designs, the most efficient designs still are HS and Popups. In DSL, you can make a killer of nearly every basic design.

Creativity/Originality: How uncommon or new is the robot's design - ranges from "clone" to" never before seen". However, overly new designs sometimes tend to be less efficient than old and more "experienced" robot designs. There are exceptions, like when Popups and Jugglers were created for the first time.

Looks: Some builders pay special attention on their robot's cool looks. May be component placement, artful paintjob or both. Note that sacrificing sheer efficiency for better looks can happen easily.